Exceptional Gourmet Cheese Every Day

Our selection of 400+ Domestic and Imported Cheeses are carefully selected and cut fresh daily. Don’t know what pairs well with Chardonnay? Want a sample? Ask our cheese experts – they’ll answer your pairing questions, provide samples, and prepare cheese boards by request. Most importantly, they’ll send you home with the highest quality, most flavorful cheeses, including some of your favorite organic brands like Rumiano, Sierra Nevada™ Cheese, Trickling Springs, and Applegate. And, our catering department can prepare handmade sandwiches & catering trays for any occasion.

  • McCaffrey’s Aged Cheddar Cheese
  • Armigiano Reggiano 24-Month Export
  • Divina Dig Spreads
  • Buttermilk Blue Cheese
  • McCaffrey’s Double Crème Brie Cheese

Hand-Picked Tips

Looking for something special for your holiday gatherings? Try our McCaffrey’s International Cheese Flight which includes:

  • Brie Cheese
  • Gouda Cheese
  • Asiago Cheese
  • Havarti Cheese
  • Gruyere Cheese
  • Huntsman Cheese
  • Fresh Strawberries
  • Red & Green Grapes
  • Dried Apricots
  • Figs
  • Orange Blossom Honey
The cheese board presentation makes a beautiful centerpiece for your table and is all you need to serve as a starter! As always, our experts in our Gourmet Cheese Departments can help you select cheeses and charcuterie to build your own cheese & charcuterie boards, or they can create custom boards for you.

Have Questions About Gourmet Cheese?

Ask Our Expert

How Can We Help You Today?

Due to ongoing staffing issues, our deli departments will be closing at 7pm daily until further notice.
West Windsor's deli department will be closing at 6pm. We apologize for the inconvenience.