Exceptional Dairy, Grocery & Frozen Foods Every Day

Grocery – While you’re doing your everyday shop, we hope you’ll notice something exceptional at McCaffrey’s Food Markets. We offer more than 1,000 organic selections, close to 5,000 specialty items and literally thousands of natural ingredients and products. Besides our McCaffrey’s private label, we specialize in Organic, GMO- and Gluten-Free foods that are packed with nutrients and simply taste great. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff is here to answer all of your questions and help you find all of the items on your listOr, consult our circular for a sampling of the thousands of items we have on sale every day.

Dairy – While we continue to carry your favorites, we have been introducing more organic/Non-GMO, all natural, gluten- and lactose-free products to better suit everyone’s unique needs. And, you don’t have to drive to a micro-dairy. Travel no further than our Dairy Department for McCaffrey’s own, hormone-free milk. Speaking of local, Kreider Farm – a working farm in Lancaster County – supplies fresh quality dairy products to our Food Markets. Talk to one of our experts in the dairy aisle: we’ll help you choose what you need for your family.

Frozen Foods – Customers have their choice of exceptional frozen food at McCaffrey’s. We stock more than 2,000 frozen food offerings – from all-natural side dishes to gourmet-inspired entrees and absolutely delicious desserts. Everything to make a perfect, no-fuss dinner without the mess . . . and prep time. At McCaffrey’s, we’ve been making our recipes exactly as you would at home. All of the frozen food brands we stock use the finest ingredients. Many varieties contain no additives, no preservatives, no gluten, and no GMO’s.

  • Cardini’s Salad Dressing
  • Chocolove Chocolate Bars
  • Waterloo Sparkling Water
  • Quinn Filled Pretzel Nuggets
  • Rao’s Homemade Marinara Sauce
  • Milk Bar Cookies
  • Purely Elizabeth Organic Cereal
  • Lily’s Chocolate Bars

Hand-Picked Tips

What do you get when you slow cook sweet Italian plum tomatoes, olive oil, onions, salt & pepper, basil, and oregano? Rao's Homemade® Marinara Sauce. This classic sauce pairs well with our McCaffrey’s homemade Italian sausage in this recipe for Penne with Tomato and Italian Sausage. You can always add more herbs if you prefer – a pinch more garlic, Italian seasoning, parsley, or basil, but it’s a customer favorite on its own. Try it if you haven't already; it will become your go to sauce for all things Pasta!

Have Questions About Grocery, Dairy and Frozen Foods?

Ask Our Expert

How Can We Help You Today?

MEMORIAL DAY HOURS: All locations will be open 7am - 7pm on Monday, 5/30.