Exceptional Seafood Every Day

Our Seafood Department has everything you need to create an exceptionally healthy meal. Our friendly seafood experts can help you choose from whatever catch the fisherman lands daily. You’ll find hand-cut and trimmed fillets, or fresh – never frozen – steaks for the grill. If you prefer, we’ll do the preparation for you, like steamed lobsters or shucked oysters. Perfectly trimmed, ready-to-cook items might be just the bait necessary to lure the most discerning taste buds. We’re happy to help you choose from our high quality seafood and give you tips on how to prepare and cook it. And, our catering department can prepare a beautiful fish platter or tray for any occasion.

  • McCaffrey’s Fresh Store-Made 2 lb. (26-30) Shrimp Trays
  • Lobster Tails
  • Jumbo Choice Baccala
  • Fresh Whole Bronzini
  • 16/20 Ex-Jumbo Cooked & Cleaned Shrimp
  • Fresh Faroe Islands Salmon Fillet
  • Fresh, Never Frozen, Dry Sea Scallops
  • McCaffrey’s Fresh Raw Gourmet Crab Cakes
  • Catsmo/Noir Caviar

Hand-Picked Tips

Did you know that our seafood associates can skin and portion a fish for you while you wait or continue shopping? We can also poach a whole salmon or provide you with a smoked fish platter, upon request! Just ask! We’d love to put together a fresh, store-made Shrimp Tray for you, as well. It includes 2 lbs. or  26-30 shrimp and is perfect for the get-togethers that continue well into 2026! Throw any leftover shrimp into this recipe for Shrimp and Cauliflower “Grits.” It’s heart-healthy, gluten-free, and diabetic-friendly!

Holiday Menu Tastings – December 13th 11 am – 4 pm @ all locations!

Have Questions About Seafood?

If you need help with a seafood order, please call your local store. Please do not send an order to the email inbox below.

Please note there is a 48-hour turnaround time for responses.

Ask Our Expert

How Can We Help You Today?

Due to staffing issues, Simply Fresh prepared foods and deli will be closing at 7:30 pm
and the Newtown deli will be closing at 7 pm.